X
Advanced Search
Search

Live It

Do They Know It's Christmas?

Do They Know It's Christmas?

A ding dong, merrily on high

by Mel (Mon Dec 14, 2009)
You May Also Like

Now the first time it happened, I almost didn't mind. I was so excited that finally I was getting to make a costume, that I just went with the flow. But when it happened the following year, and the one after that, and plenty more since, well, it's started to piss me off. Because, what place does a Hawaiian Hula Dancer, an octopus, a polar bear and a spangly fish have in the Nativity?

The definition of Nativity is ‘Birth; the place, conditions, or circumstances of being born.' But everyone knows that Nativity means ‘...amateur school production portraying the birth of Jesus, alleged saviour of the World. Mary, Joseph, a donkey, the shepherds and three wise men, should all feature in this Christmas, crowd-pleasing classic.'

However, something has gone very wrong in our schools. You see along with most children in state schools in the UK, my children are not being taught the basic facts of the Nativity. My children are being fed a fudged version of the events surrounding Jesus' birth, that as the years go by becomes ever more hallucinogenic. Some coked-up scriptwriter is rubbing his nose all the way to the bank.

Let's see, what have we had? Well, that first year Jesus apparently spent a little time in Hawaii and I was required to dress my eldest in a bikini and weave a raffia skirt. Another year Jesus went all aquatic and most of the Nativity took place under the sea, with my son doing an Irish dance dressed as an octopus (I wish I were making this up). There was one joyful year when Jesus went back to basics and my daughter was - hallelujah! - an angel. Then there was the year of environmental concern and Jesus hung out with the polar bears (my son) and the year of the spangly fish was just too awful to mention.

What is going on? Why is this happening? I've broached the subject with teachers and they shrug and mumble about ‘appealing to all faiths.' Why? Why should we appeal to all faiths? What sort of watered-down nonsense is that? If you want to appeal to all faiths, then by all means celebrate Diwali in - er - Diwali time, have some Yom Kippur as and when, and leave some oranges lying around for that Hindi elephant with lots of arms. That's absolutely fine by me, but don't hallucinate up a ridiculous story that embraces all faiths, all persecuted minorities, all skin colours and any wheelchair-bound asylum seekers that are left.

Hey, and here's an idea, if you want to appeal to all faiths, why don't you start by not bombing their homes? I'm going out on a limb here, but if you invade a couple of Muslim countries using a flimsy pretext, cause death and destruction and ignite civil war, well I reckon there's a good chance that you're not endearing yourself to that particular faith. And by dressing a token child in a hijab at the next Nativity, well, that‘s probably not going to win the battle for hearts and minds now is it? Just a thought, you know, in case you're really serious about that appealing to all faiths thing.

Isn't it time we came clean about the true meaning of the Nativity? It's not really about Jesus, Mary and Joseph at all. It's about feeling excited because it's nearly Christmas and we‘ll get loads of presents. It's about singing hymns from our childhood that are beautiful. It's about a fairy tale on a par with an inspired episode of the Simpsons, but a fairy tale that is familiar and comforting nevertheless. It‘s about watching our children forget their lines and pick their noses whilst dressed as sheep. It's about tradition, not religion, and it's harmless.

So this year, please, let's have yon virgin mother and child, shepherds who watch their flocks by night, a star that is westward leading still proceeding and three traversing kings from the Orient (there's scope for an ethnic minority there I grant you) who are bearing Gold, Frankincense and Myrrh.

And please God, this year make my son a shepherd so that he can wear a tea-towel on his head.

Great Graffiti 17 people liked this
Add a Comment 11 Comments
Threaded View
|
Expand All
Show:
Oldest First
|
Newest First
|
Most Popular First
Cancel

Please login before commenting and you'll be able to manage your comments.

Preview Submit
Mel
Posted Wed Dec 16, 2009 at 10:18 pm Reply Delete
Great to read all your comments...some more - er - coherent than others. In fact a special mention for Rosen, you really did brighten my day, especially your opening gambit! @zoolady, confusingly in the UK, unless it is a faith school, religion does not get taught. Except that it does because the children learn all about other religions apart from the Christian one. And then at Christmas they put on a truly garbled show, that always features Mary, Joseph and baby Jesus, but also polar bears, spangly fish, belly dancing camels (it's true Millicent!) and various other random creatures. I find it exasperating, I'm going to suggest they do a pantomime next year. I wonder if I've cleared that query up for you?!!Report Abuse
MaryH
Posted Tue Dec 15, 2009 at 9:25 pm Reply Delete
Thank goodness that there are people like Rosen in the world to set us all straight on right and wrong. And here we were having an exchange of thoughts and ideas and all we needed to do was to call this person to set us straight. We're lucky ladies today. Thanks Rosen.Report Abuse
Rosen
Posted Tue Dec 15, 2009 at 8:52 pm Reply Delete
You poor fool. Rather than worrying that your rediculously primitive myths aren't being properly conveyed to your children. Why don't y0u get a clue and let the educators at least help your kids out of the stone age. It's religious traditions that are perpetuating the lions share of social problems and ingonarance and you are making your children the victims. Shut your mouth and read a science book.Report Abuse
jo
Posted Tue Dec 15, 2009 at 8:34 pm Reply Delete
How about this for PC gone haywire: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,580282,00.html?test=latestnewsReport Abuse
Posted Tue Dec 15, 2009 at 3:18 pm Reply Delete
The school would be better off to not have a 'Nativity Play' at all if it cannot truly be about the nativity. Dancing octopus and Hawaiian skirts is down right insulting. Since when did celebrating Christmas become so controversial? Children have days off from school in the US for both Christian and non Christian holidays, there is nothing wrong with teaching kids about all the different traditions, then maybe each generation might become MORE tolerant of all religi0ns and they we can all stop bombing each other. IMAGINE?Report Abuse
Sarah
Posted Mon Dec 14, 2009 at 11:00 pm Reply Delete
I don't think the political correctness of not wanting to offend non-Christians is something that has come about because of wars in the Middle East. And, while I agree with your sentiment about not watering down religious traditions but rather give others equal time, how exactly would you do that? Aren't there just too many faiths and things to be respected? Finally, Christmas is not about presents. It is about the birth of Christ and if I do not believe in that, I should not have it forced upon me at a state funded school regardless of whether the players are dressed as fish or in accordance with the true biblical tale.Report Abuse
Posted Mon Dec 14, 2009 at 7:19 pm Reply Delete
On a serious note...are you talking about publicly-supported schools? Do schools present Christian nativity myths as part of the curriculum? I understand if it's a private, religious school...but what about the children who aren't Christian/religious at all?Report Abuse
Milicent
Posted Mon Dec 14, 2009 at 6:05 pm Reply Delete
Just you wait it's bikini clad belly dancing camels this year! followed by a summer of non competitive sports days!! hee heeReport Abuse
Posted Mon Dec 14, 2009 at 4:00 pm Reply Delete
I blame the film Love Actually - they had an octopus and a lobster in their nativity play. But I bet your kids didn't get the PM kissing one of his staff behind the curtains at their performance!Report Abuse
caz
Posted Mon Dec 14, 2009 at 2:20 pm Reply Delete
All it needs is to finish up with John Lennon's 'Imagine' instead of 'Away in a Manger' and you have the perfect school nativity play!Report Abuse
Ali Armstrong
Posted Mon Dec 14, 2009 at 11:32 am Reply Delete
God, you're good! To use a familiar Bristolian expression: "You made I larf!" Go girl!Report Abuse

Advanced Search Search

Graffiti to Go

A space for you to share your recommendations of sites, services and special things with other readers.

Video Graffiti

Women! Know Your Limits! View all videos